Samsung Cites Time's 'Ovation' in Blu-ray Mixed Review

August 2, 2006
It can be amusing how two parties can see the same product review and walk away with very different opinions of what it says. A few days ago, Samsung sent out its monthly "Samsung Ovations" e-mail that typically includes positive reviews of its products.

One review that caught our eye was Samsung's heads up this week that a noted magazine had tapped its new Blu-ray disc player as its "Gadget of the Week" under Samsung's headline, "Time Talks Up the BD-P1000 Blu-ray Disc Player." Yet a quick look at the review found something a bit more subdued than an ovation.

While the June 28 review by Time's Wilson Rothman, at one point, did refer to the Samsung unit as producing a "smooth and flawless" picture, it wasn't without some difficulty for the Time reviewer to view the "picture," to begin with. Rothman said that the first set of new Blu-ray discs he tried were not recognized by the new player (although it did recognize a traditional DVD disc right away).

The reviewer said it took nearly a day for the Blu-ray player to start accepting Blu-ray discs (including the previously rejected ones). Samsung, the review noted, assured Time that the problem could be overcome with a firmware upgrade via a disc. (This apparently was not the same correctible problem, later noted by Samsung, which also affected the BD-P1000. See HD Notebook, July 26, 2006.)

Rothman reported that Samsung assured him the review samples were not from the same production run as the ones now on retail shelves, "but I still urge caution. The BD-P1000 is first-generation equipment, and it, like Toshiba's HD DVD player, may be buggy."

The Time reviewer said (also cited in the firm's Samsung Ovations e-mail), "Once again, tables may turn when the $600 Blu-ray-equipped PlayStation 3 launches this November, but for the moment, Samsung's Blu-ray player costs twice as much as Toshiba's HD DVD player, and just isn't twice as good."

Related Articles

Telestream Tempo Time Adjustment Software Now Shipping

Samsung, Pearl and Sinclair Gear Up for ATSC 3.0 Dry Runs

2015 NAB Audio Review

Receive regular news and technology updates.
Sign up for our free newsletter here.