Standard General Lashes Out at FCC for Delaying Tegna Deal Approval
Calls the FCC decision to refer questions to administrative law judge an attempt “to scuttle the deal” by further delaying approval and vows to complete the transaction
WASHINGTON, D.C.—Following the FCC’s decision to refer some questions regarding Standard General’s proposed acquisition of Tegna to an administrative law judge on Feb. 24, Standard General has vowed to complete the transaction and issued a strongly worded statement on Feb. 27 calling the move an unprecedented attempt to scuttle the proposed deal.
It also noted that the Media Bureau’s action, which was promptly criticized by two of the FCC’s four current Commissioners, is tantamount to denying the transaction by initiating a lengthy process that would extend well beyond the transaction’s Final Extension Date of May 22, 2023.
“A decision delayed is a decision denied,” Standard General’s managing partner Soo Kim said. “Our proposed transaction is consistent with all FCC regulations and precedent. It is bolstered by a voluntary commitment to invest in local news, preserve newsroom jobs, and address purported concerns related to consumer pricing. But rather than rule on the transaction’s merits, as the law requires, the Media Bureau is attempting to scuttle the deal by ordering a wholly unnecessary hearing process that if left standing by the Commission, would kill the deal.”
“The unavoidable implication is that this particular transaction may be scuttled not due to substantive or evidence-based concerns, but rather by the Media Bureau’s unexplained view that Standard General simply should not be allowed to own these television stations and that any future applicant to acquire TEGNA or any other TV station group must meet the test of being acceptable to the Media Bureau in its sole, absolute, and unreviewable discretion,” Kim concluded. “This precedent, if allowed to stand unchallenged, will turn the “Public Interest” standard on its head by restricting investment in and ownership of wide swaths of the economy to those deemed acceptable by regulators.”
In reporting its Q4 2022 earnings on Feb. 27, shortly before Standard General issued its statement on the FCC actions, Tegna noted in a filing with the Securities & Exchange Commission that on Feb. 21, 2023, Tegna elected, pursuant to the terms of the Merger Agreement, to extend the final date for completing the deal to May 22, 2023. The filing also said that following the FCC’s decision to refer some questions regarding the deal to an administrative law judge, “Tegna is currently evaluating its options.”
In criticizing the decision to refer issues to an administrative law judge, Standard General also reiterated a number points it has made in filings to the FCC and press releases:
- "This transaction, which actually makes Tegna smaller as a result of the subtraction of several of its largest stations, complies with all FCC ownership rules and precedent and requires no waivers. The applicable waiting period under the HSR Act has expired.
- The FCC had this transaction under review for 354 days and counting. Not only is this long past the FCC’s own informal 180-day ‘shot clock’ but will soon become the longest reviewed major television broadcast sale ever.
- Over the course of the extended review process, the FCC has opened an unprecedented three separate Public Comment Processes.
- All throughout this period, the Media Bureau has consistently declined our requests to meet to address any concerns it might have. The Media Bureau has never provided any feedback to our responses. The very questions raised in the Hearing Designation Order we have responded multiple times going back to July 2022. Note our voluntary remedies were proposed without the benefit of feedback from the FCC or from the objectors despite every attempt to engage with them.
- Unlike previous proposed transactions that have been blocked by the FCC, there is no allegation that this deal violates any FCC rule, nor are any of the parties accused of any inappropriate action or conduct.
- To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time that the FCC has acted through the Media Bureau in a manner designed to kill a pending transaction:
- Without referencing a single rule or regulation that the proposed transaction might violate.
- Without any consideration of conditions that would address any outstanding concerns.
- By raising issues that fall outside the Media Bureau’s authority.
- By designating it for evidentiary hearing despite having already received all relevant documents and internal communications in the unprecedented two prior document productions.
- And much less a transaction of this magnitude without a full vote of the Commission.
- The transaction advances the FCC’s stated goal of increasing diversity in media ownership, representing the biggest opportunity in history to expand minority-ownership and woman-leadership of local broadcast television stations.
- Despite some of the objectors denying that our ownership would satisfy this FCC-stated goal, a wide array of civil rights organizations, legislators and labor and minority media groups submitted supportive comments to the FCC, detailing the many ways in which this transaction would advance the public interest.
- In all these respects, the Media Bureau’s actions stand in sharp contrast to other recent broadcast transactions which required special FCC actions, yet were all approved by the Commission in a timely manner," Standard General said.
The latest product and technology information
Future US's leading brands bring the most important, up-to-date information right to your inbox
George Winslow is the senior content producer for TV Tech. He has written about the television, media and technology industries for nearly 30 years for such publications as Broadcasting & Cable, Multichannel News and TV Tech. Over the years, he has edited a number of magazines, including Multichannel News International and World Screen, and moderated panels at such major industry events as NAB and MIP TV. He has published two books and dozens of encyclopedia articles on such subjects as the media, New York City history and economics.