WASHINGTON: The U.S. Department of Justice
has approved a $3.6 billion spectrum deal between Verizon Wireless and three cable
operators, with some conditions imposed.
“The proposed settlement forbids Verizon Wireless from selling cable company products
in FiOS areas and removes contractual restrictions on Verizon Wireless’s ability
to sell FiOS, ensuring that Verizon’s incentives to compete aggressively against
the cable companies remain unchanged,” the DoJ’s statement said.
“In addition, under the proposed settlement, Verizon Wireless’s ability to resell
the cable companies’ services to customers in areas where Verizon sells DSL Internet
service ends in December of 2016.”
Verizon announced last December that it agreed to buy advanced wireless spectrum
held by SpectrumCo, a consortium of Comcast, Time Warner Cable and Bright House
Networks, for $3.6 billion. The deal included a cross-marketing agreement whereby
the cable companies would sell Verizon Wireless service, and vice versa. The deal
drew fire from competitors and close scrutiny from regulators. As the review dragged
on, Verizon announced in January that it would offload some of the SpectrumCo AWS
if the deal were approved.
Verizon proceeded to launch cross-marketing efforts on a city-by-city basis, which
the DoJ’s Antitrust Division, along with the New York State Attorney General’s office,
has filed a civil antitrust lawsuit with the U.S. District Court for the D.C. Circuit,
to stop. Should Verizon agree to the DoJ’s proposed settlement terms, it will be
“Verizon and the cable companies are direct competitors in many local markets throughout
the United States where Verizon offers video, voice and broadband service. The series
of commercial agreements between Verizon and the cable companies would have threatened
this competition,” the DoJ said. “Most notably, the agreements, as originally structured,
would have required Verizon Wireless to sell the cable companies’ services on an
‘equivalent basis’ with FiOS where FiOS is available, thereby reducing Verizon’s
ability and incentive to sell its own services aggressively.”
Consequently, Verizon will be prohibited from reselling SpectrumCo members’ pay
TV service within its FiOS footprint, and can only market their broadband services
for five years. The DoJ also imposed an end date on a technology joint venture between
Verizon and SpectrumCo.
“The settlement also forbids any form of collusion and restricts the exchange of
competitively sensitive information. Verizon and the cable companies would also
be required to provide regular reports to the department to ensure that the collaboration
does not harm competition going forward,” the DOJ said.
The DoJ said its decision comes after a “closely coordinated investigation
with the Federal Communications Commission,” which has yet to vote on the deal.
The FCC’s Media Bureau chief Rick Kaplan today said that in addition to the conditions
described in the DoJ announcement, that Verizon Wireless had voluntarily agreed
to offer data roaming to competitors for five years, and to “substantial build-out
conditions” to be achieved by 2021.
Kaplan said he couldn’t put a timetable on the FCC vote.
FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski said he believed the commission should approve the
transaction, and that he would be circulating a draft order to his colleagues to
“Specifically, Verizon Wireless has undertaken an unprecedented divestiture of spectrum
to one of its competitors, T-Mobile, and has committed to accelerate the build-out
of its new spectrum and enhance its roaming obligations,” the chairman said in a
statement. “In addition, the companies’ commercial agreements will be modified to,
among other things, preserve Verizon’s incentives to build out FiOS, increase wireless
competition, and ensure that the proposed IP venture is pro-consumer and that its
products cannot be used in anti-competitive ways.”
Gigi Sohn, president and CEO of Public Knowledge and a long-time regulatory activist,
said the conditions were not enough to protect consumers.
“For years, policymakers have hoped that ‘facilities-based’ competition between
wired broadband providers would protect consumers, drive down prices, and encourage
new deployment,” she said in a statement. “It is clear that this promise has not
been fulfilled. Instead, Verizon has stopped deploying fiber, and will be marketing
cable broadband instead of its own services in non-fiber markets.”