Lawmakers Grill Comcast-NBCU Merger Witnesses
If today’s House subcommittee hearing is any
indication, Comcast and NBCU executives will have plenty of ’splaining to do
before legislators OK a proposed merger. Members of the House Commerce
Subcommittee on Communications, Technology and the Internet wanted assurances
that Comcast competitors would get a fair shake at the manifold video channels
the cable operator would control with 51 percent ownership of NBC.
“We will continue to abide by FCC program-access rules,” Comcast chief Brian
Roberts told Rep. Steve Buyer (R-Ind.) “That is not the motivation for this
deal, to suddenly take CNBC off of DirecTV...” or NBC’s other largest
Those rules aren’t always sufficient, one witness told subcommittee members.
Colleen Abdoulah is president and CEO of WOW!, a broadband provider in the
Midwest that competes with Comcast for around one out of five subscribers. WOW!
also buys content from both Comcast and NBCU.
“As a buyer of content, both cable and online, we face a different set of
challenges. The prospect of having Comcast and NBCU has the largest vertical
integrator of content does concern me,” she said. “We’re not here to whine, or
ask for special privileges because we’re the smaller guy. Terms and conditions
for access to content should be the same terms and conditions available to
Because they’re not, FCC program-access rules--recently modified to include
terrestrially distributed regional sports networks--did not help Abdoulah get
access to one of those networks. She described how her company was
renegotiating recently for access to one of Comcast’s regional sports networks,
and the two were about $2 million apart.
“We decided to go to arbitration,” she said. “We found out it would cost $1
million...and take 18 months.” There was no requirement for continued
provisioning of the network during arbitration, and the burden of proof is on
the party seeking program access.
“You lose programming during arbitration,” Abdoulah said. “I would have to
prove pricing wasn’t right, and I don’t have access to market data.”
Another access issue came up in the form of a conflict between Hulu and Boxee,
which makes hardware to stream Web content to TVs. Hulu is the online
distribution site for content from NBC, Fox and Disney among others. NBCU owns
a 27 percent piece of Hulu. It blocked Boxee last year from streaming its
content. When asked about the instance by Rep. Rick Boucher (D-Va.), NBCU chief
Jeff Zucker said Boxee hadn’t done a content deal with Hulu.
At least one lawmaker seemed to question the legality of the FCC’s modification
to program-access rules. Republicans Cliff Stearns of Florida, Fred Upton of
Michigan and Joe Barton of Texas stated out-and-out support for the merger.
“It’s good to see Comcast and NBC sitting side by side,” Barton said. “That
doesn’t break my heart. We’ve heard the usual predictions--this is the end of
the media world as we know it. I’m skeptical about that.”
Mary Bono Mack
(R-Calif.) wanted to
know how independent programmers would be affected, but warned that the merger
was no place to wage a network neutrality fight. Upton concurred, but Democrat
Ed Markey of Massachusetts pursued the issue nonetheless. Restricting access to
online content would be wildly tempting for one company that owned the wires
into the homes as well as the content on those wires, he said.
Markey conjured up the example of a kid starting the next online phenomena with
“The Avatar Network,” and how, without network neutrality conditions, it might
never get off the ground. Roberts responded that “The Avatar Network” is just
the type of content Comcast would want developed.
The fate of NBC’s 200 or so network affiliates was on the mind of Doris Matsui,
Democrat from Sacramento, Calif., where KCRA-TV is the NBC station.
“I want to ensure that KCRA is not put at a competitive disadvantage,” she
Michael Fiorile, chief of The Dispatch Co., and head of NBC affiliate board
said the merger could compromise affiliates.
“We currently negotiate with NBC for
affiliation; and separately with the cable carrier for carriage,” he said. “The
potential exists for the network to withhold the affiliation if retransmission
consent negotiations came to a standstill. We want a structural separation of
Zucker responded that he didn’t foresee a need for a structural separation. The
House hearing ended with some members requesting written responses to questions
because witnesses were scheduled to appear at a similar hearing with the Senate
Comcast proposed in early December to take a majority stake in NBC Universal
from General Electric for roughly $8 billion. The deal has to pass through the
Justice Department or the Federal Trade Commission, and the FCC, through which
lawmakers will attempt to impose conditions.
-- Deborah D. McAdams
(Image by Scott