Deborah D. McAdams /
07.20.2012 02:51PM
McAdams On: Madness at Midnight
LOS ANGELES: I intended to focus on inanity of retransmission squabbles being “news,” but I have family in Aurora, Colo. An alleged person there slipped off the rails and sprayed bullets into a theater full of folks attending a midnight screening of the new Batman film. Reports are indicating that 12 people were killed and possibly as many as 59 injured.

The local police already have a suspect, whose name is appearing in headlines across the media. I will not repeat it here because to me, it’s blasphemous to the families and loved ones of those 12 massacred individuals. It’s common knowledge that psychopaths crave attention, and by nightfall, this mouth-frothing murderous freak will be a notorious celebrity. What he should be is relegated quietly to an interrogation room until the District Attorney can get him locked in a cell for the rest of his life. Instead of headlines on front pages blaring, “Lone Gunman,” his name should come out months from now, buried on page six and prefaced with, “impotent, cowardly lunatic.”

I’m not suggesting that the media drives these deranged individuals to commit horrible acts. The media is already blamed for more than it could ever intentionally accomplish. The media, while comprised of journalists, is also an organism independent of the individuals who make it up, due in large part to the Internet. Most journalists I know are overworked, underpaid, sleep-deprived, schlemiels whose intention to defend the First Amendment has devolved into a tap dance of traffic, ratings and what can be sold against.

The business has always been colored by manipulation and flummery—no question. But before digital journalism, there was a little more time to actually vet breaking news before going out with it.
Mistakes were still made, don't get me wrong. I was on print deadline at B&C several years ago when a tip came in that Barry Diller was buying a network, and I had to chase it down. A long-time industry analyst pointed me toward GoodLife TV, a network then owned by the Unification Church. Barry bought Trio, about as not GoodLife as you could get. Had the printers not been drumming fingers waiting for me, I would have hounded people with phone calls into the night, but I didn’t stall and I got it wrong.

I understand the buck stopped squarely with me, despite the extenuating circumstances. I also understand how much worse the pressure to publish is in the digital age, when “breaking” news comes down to seconds, and your stock in trade is clicks. So it is then, that when Matt Drudge, a subversive conservative tool masquerading as a journalist, squeezes out some gossip about Condoleezza Rice as a running mate for Mitt Romney, it races through the media like a wildfire, overtaking “legitimate” journalists late to identify it as a apparatchik trial balloon.

They got it wrong, just like I did more than a decade ago—and of course I’ve made mistakes since then. Everyone makes mistakes every day. The cultural taboo of admitting it doesn’t make it less true. It just makes us all less honest, like people who regularly mislead reporters for their own gain, or because they can—as Drudge did. The retransmission brannigans over the last couple of weeks illustrate the first situation. These things have been going on for more than a decade. There’s absolutely nothing new from one to the next.

Neither party reveals numbers in any sort of relevant context, but rather in whatever way best reflects on their own position. Both take to the media as if they’re single-handedly defending baseball, mom and apple pie, and we dutifully report their baloney as if it’s actual news rather than a wholesale attempt to influence policy. What we should be covering is why, if retransmission fees are responsible for escalating cable bills as providers claim, don’t they refund subscribers during the network blackouts for which they are partially responsible? That always ends up being an aside.

I have issues with people who manipulate the media, even though I am knowingly and otherwise handled myself. Does my gullibility somehow reduce me more than someone else’s willingness to lie, like the person called “Ryan Holiday,” who apparently makes it his business to lie to the media, according to Forbes, if they haven’t been lied to. He practices a sort of reverse “gotcha” by posing as a legitimate source. He proceeds to spin fabrications, and then brags about having his lies quoted. How this is doing anything other than serving his ego, I do not know. It’s not just my First Amendment. It’s everyone’s First Amendment, and lying to reporters does nothing but degrade us all.

Copy editors and fact checkers were among the first to go in the downsizing that’s taken place across media companies over the last decade. Maybe there’s a business model for a sort of AP-type service that just copy edits and vets. Mr. Holiday could start such a universal copy desk. It would be a bit more constructive than lobbing verbal Molotovs.

That said, the need for institutional redirection remains. As long as we breathlessly cover retransmission fights like conflagrations, the companies involved will feed us as much dry tinder as we can burn.

As for mass murderers—they walk freely among us, headlines or otherwise. I just wish the practice of glorification by headline would disappear from the face of the Earth, along with their kind. As far as I know, my family is OK. Scores of other Colorado families are not. With the greatest and most profound sadness, I am so sorry.

Post Script: Whether it was symptomatic of breaking news neurosis or sheer stupidity, there appears to be no excuse whatsoever for ABC’s huge gaffe linking the Colorado murderer to the Tea Party. I look forward to the organization's explanation.


Comments
Post New Comment
If you are already a member, or would like to receive email alerts as new comments are
made, please login or register.

Enter the code shown above:

(Note: If you cannot read the numbers in the above
image, reload the page to generate a new one.)

1.
Posted by: Anonymous
Sat, 07-21-2012 - 5:18AM Report Comment
ABC's huge gaffe? That was no gaffe. They found a Tea Party guy with the same very common name, probably one of dozens in the state, and went with it because it fit their biases. ABC and Drudge are two sides of the same coin. Truth has no place in journalism. It's all stories. They only turn to reality for source material when their imaginations fail them, which is a lot of the time. Then they distort it to fit their biases. If you really want truth, reality, objectivity, and good judgment as to how important a story is, well, you just have to turn to NHK Newsline. They gave it maybe half a minute before going to the Syria story.
2.
Posted by: Anonymous
Fri, 07-20-2012 - 8:00PM Report Comment
wow Deb .. you can publish this or not - you have that option ... I've just been watching the coverage on my media wall and came down to check email and move on with my life here in the midwest .. your post set me up to have this conversation with you: 1st the Phd neuroscience student gone off the rails - I've seen the movies we produce out of Hollywood - I've seen the twists of real life in the news ... simply put two drama thrillers come to mind for you to consider and then say "NA, Cant Be" - but real journalists should be open to possiblities a: "Manchurian Candidate"x2 b: "Shooter" with Mark Wahlberg ... I would really Like to see the arrest at the car in the back of the theater on policecarCam - a: subject was covered HeadToToe in OpGear and could have been involved in an elaborate switch out or even weirder SciFi stuff - "NA, Cant Be" .. its early & I see they are still attempting entry into this guys apartment ie its boobytrapped ... on both scenarios a: cut & dry real b: insaine BlackOp plan > WHY / maybe to be the talk of the town (world) ... 2nd beyond all that before submit - I'm waiting for news on what door this BlackOpGuy got in - that gear "it looked like toys"? ... who what where when why how Greg Stein - Oglesby, IL aka Graphics Plus+ and Greg0658




Thursday 2:01PM
IBC APP Now Available
I downloaded the app and found it useful for my main IBC pitfall


 
Featured Articles
Discover TV Technology